BinderMint

How to grade sports cards yourself

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: Look at four things: centering, corners, edges and surface. Compare each to a published grading scale, and send in only cards that look clean on all four.

Step 1: Check centering

Use a ruler on the side borders first, then the borders above and below the picture. Turn each pair into a ratio, like 55/45. CGC's published scale lets a Gem Mint 10 front run to about 55/45, while a Mint 9 front is 60/40 or better. A back at 90/10 can still be a Mint 9.

Step 2: Check corners

Look at all four corners in bright light. CGC describes a Mint 9 as four sharp corners with minor wear. Corners with a touch of wear on three or more corners fall to Near Mint 7. A magnifier helps, because CGC's scale describes Gem Mint 10 corners as Mint+ under 10x magnification.

Step 3: Check edges and surface

Tilt the card under a lamp. Look for chips, rough edges, print spots, scratches and loss of gloss. CGC says a Gem Mint 10 surface has no print spots and perfect gloss, while a Mint 9 may have a few specks or one minor spot.

Step 4: Match what you see to a grade

GradeWhat CGC's scale says
Gem Mint 10Corners perfect to the naked eye, perfect gloss, centering about 55/45 or better
Mint 9Four sharp corners with minor wear, centering 60/40 front
Near Mint/Mint 8Smooth edges with minor wear, centering 65/35 or better
Near Mint 7Touch of wear on three or more corners, centering 70/30 or better

Your own grade is a guess. Graders see more than you do, so treat a self-grade as a way to rank your cards, not as a promise.

Keep notes on what you find

Write the centering ratio and any flaw next to each card, then sort them into send-in and keep-raw piles. A spreadsheet works, and so does an app. See free card collection trackers for options. For very rare numbered cards, read our one-of-one cards guide. BinderMint is a card catalog app. One photo finds up to 9 cards.

FAQ

Can I grade my own sports cards?

You can check them against a published scale. The grade a company gives is the one that counts.

What is the first thing to check?

Centering. It is the easiest part to measure with a ruler.

What centering does a top grade need?

CGC says a Gem Mint 10 front is no worse than about 55/45.

Should I grade every card?

Send in cards that look clean on centering, corners, edges and surface. Keep the rest raw.

Last checked 11 November 2026.

Sources

Related