BinderMint

How to inventory your cards for insurance

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: List each card, photograph the valuable ones, keep receipts, and store a copy away from home. Then ask your insurer what it needs. This guide repeats what the sources below say. It is not insurance advice. Checked October 27, 2026.

What do the sources say to record?

Where should you keep the inventory?

Three copies of a card inventoryA card list with descriptions, photos, prices, receipts and storage places is copied three ways: at home, in a digital copy, and outside the home.Your card list• What each card is• Photos• What you paid• Receipts• Where keptA copy at homeA digital copydrive or onlineA copy outsideyour home
Keep at least one copy outside your home. A partial list beats none.

Does your policy cover cards?

SourceWhat it says
Upper DeckMany policies limit the payout for a sports card collection. Its example is $200.
Insurance Information InstituteCollectibles may need coverage separate from a standard homeowners policy. Ask your agent before a loss.
Collectibles Insurance ServicesSays it does not require a schedule or appraisal for most sports memorabilia items, but you must keep your own inventory. Items or sets valued over $25,000 apiece must be scheduled. It says new items must be reported within 30 to 90 days.

Rules differ by insurer and policy. Call yours and ask what proof it needs for cards.

What should an insurance card list hold?

BinderMint turns a photo of a binder page into a list. It reads each card's name, set, year and number. Prices are eBay asking prices, not sold prices, so they are not an appraisal. The free plan holds 99 cards. Collector holds 499 cards for $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year. Vault holds 1,144 cards and costs $5.99 a month or $49.99 a year.

FAQ

What should a card inventory include?

A description, what you paid, photos, and receipts or appraisals. Upper Deck adds estimated value, condition and special features.

Does homeowners insurance cover my cards?

It may be limited. Ask your insurer what your policy says.

Where should I keep the inventory?

Keep one copy outside your home and one digital copy.

Sources

Last checked October 27, 2026.

Related