BinderMint

What are the most valuable 1968 Topps baseball cards?

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: As of November 2026, the top 1968 Topps baseball sale is a #177 Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman rookie in PSA 10 at $612,359.83 on Aug 26, 2016, as Wikipedia lists it. A PSA 10 Ryan rookie also drew a $500,000 winning bid at Goldin Auctions in August 2020, and a PSA 10 #247 Johnny Bench rookie brought $75,000 at Robert Edward Auctions in Fall 2023.

Which 1968 Topps sales top the list?

Each row is one copy in one grade, sold on one date. Another copy in the same grade can sell for more or less.

CardGradePriceSale dateSeller
Nolan Ryan / Jerry Koosman #177 rookiePSA 10$612,359.83Aug 26, 2016Not stated
Nolan Ryan #177 (Mets Rookie Stars)PSA 10$500,000Aug 2020Goldin Auctions
Nolan Ryan #177 rookiePSA 9$115,000Aug 23, 2025Not stated
Johnny Bench #247 rookiePSA 10$75,000Fall 2023Robert Edward Auctions
Nolan Ryan #177 rookiePSA 9$73,800Oct 2025Robert Edward Auctions
Nolan Ryan #177 (Mets Rookie Stars)PSA 9$69,000Fall 2023Robert Edward Auctions
Mickey Mantle #280PSA 8$2,400Spring 2022Robert Edward Auctions

How rare is a top-grade Bench rookie?

The auction listing for the PSA 10 Bench said PSA had given that grade to 16 of the 11,572 Bench rookies sent in for grading.

The Ryan rookie shows how much one grade step moves the price: a PSA 9 sold for $69,000 at Robert Edward Auctions in Fall 2023, far below the $500,000 winning bid for a PSA 10.

Where does Mantle fit?

Mantle #280 is a star card but not the top price in this set. A PSA 8 copy sold for $2,400 at Robert Edward Auctions in Spring 2022.

Keeping a 1968 run in order

Sort the set by card number with a sports card binder layout, and learn how errors differ from variations before you pay a premium for a strange print.

Snap the card and BinderMint names it and shows its eBay asking price.

FAQ

What is the most valuable 1968 Topps card?

The #177 Nolan Ryan rookie. A PSA 10 Ryan / Jerry Koosman copy sold for $612,359.83 on Aug 26, 2016, and a PSA 10 Ryan copy went for $500,000 at Goldin in August 2020.

How much did a PSA 10 Johnny Bench rookie sell for?

$75,000 at Robert Edward Auctions in its Fall 2023 sale.

Is a 1968 Mantle card worth a lot?

Grade decides it. A PSA 8 copy of #280 sold for $2,400 at Robert Edward Auctions in Spring 2022.

How do I price my own 1968 copy?

Look for sold results of the same card number in the same grade from the last few months.

Last checked 16 November 2026.

Sources

Related