BinderMint

PSA vs BGS vs SGC

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: The three graders use different scales. PSA's top grade is a 10 Gem Mint. BGS adds four subgrades, and its top grade is a 10 Pristine. SGC has two 10s. PSA's Standard service costs $59.99 per card. Beckett and SGC prices could not be checked.

How do the PSA, BGS and SGC scales compare side by side?

GraderTop gradesWhat stands out
PSA 10 Gem Mint, 9 Mint, 8 Near Mint-Mint, 7 Near Mint, 6 Excellent-Mint Whole numbers only. A 10 needs front centering of about 55/45 or better.
BGS (Beckett) 10 Pristine, 9.5 Gem Mint Half grades. Four subgrades: centering, corners, edges, surface. The overall grade is not a plain average. The Black Label needs four 10 subgrades.
SGC 10 Pristine, 10 Gem Mint, 9.5 Mint+, 9 Mint, 8 Near Mint-Mint Pristine needs 50/50 centering. Gem Mint allows 55/45 or better.

What does this mean when you compare?

Number that means Gem MintThree bars show the number each company uses for Gem Mint: PSA 10, BGS 9.5, SGC 10. BGS is the odd one out.Number that means Gem MintPSAGem Mint10BGSGem Mint9.5SGCGem Mint10BGS Gem Mint is 9.5. PSA Gem Mint is 10.
Same name, different number. Match the grader and the grade before you compare a price.

What does PSA charge per card?

PSA lists these per-card prices on its own trading card grading page, checked on 21 October 2026. The page says value services are paused for now. Turnaround times are PSA's estimates.

PSA servicePrice per cardMax insured valueEstimated turnaround
Standard$59.99$1,00090 to 100 business days
Priority$79.99$1,50070 to 80 business days
Express$199.00$2,50020 to 30 business days
Super Express$349.00$5,00010 to 15 business days
Premier$599.00$10,0007 to 10 business days

Beckett's pricing page showed a security check, so its prices are not listed. Sports Collectors Daily and cardgrade.io reported that SGC raised its base grading price from $15 to $50 per card on 2 September 2026, and SGC has said the structure may change again. Sports Collectors Daily also reported that Beckett paused its Base and Standard services in August 2026; check Beckett's site for what is open now. We could not open SGC's or Beckett's own price tables to confirm. Check each site before you submit.

Listing cards before you choose a grader

BinderMint reads each card's name, set, year and number from a photo of a binder page. Use it to list the cards you want to compare before you grade. It shows eBay asking prices, not sold prices. The free plan holds 99 cards. Collector holds 499 cards for $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year. Vault holds 1,144 cards and costs $5.99 a month or $49.99 a year.

Two more graders are covered in the CGC fee guide, the SGC fee guide and the TAG grading guide.

FAQ

Is a PSA 10 the same as a BGS 10?

No. PSA 10 is Gem Mint. BGS 10 is Pristine. BGS calls its 9.5 Gem Mint.

What are BGS subgrades?

Scores for centering, corners, edges and surface. The overall grade is not a plain average.

What does the SGC Pristine 10 mean?

SGC has two 10s. Pristine needs 50/50 centering. Gem Mint allows 55/45 or better.

How much does each grader cost?

On 21 October 2026, PSA listed $59.99 per card for Standard, up to $599.00 for Premier. Beckett and SGC prices could not be checked. Prices change, so check each grader's site.

Sources

PSA prices come from PSA's own page. The scales come from third-party pages.

Last checked 22 October 2026.

Related