BinderMint

1976 Topps football: which card brings the most?

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: As of November 2026, the top 1976 Topps football sale is a signed Walter Payton #148 rookie, graded PSA 7 / Auto 10, at $280,600 through Heritage Auctions on March 2, 2026. The top unsigned sale is an SGC 100 (Gold Label Pristine) copy at $228,000 through Heritage on February 26, 2021.

Payton rookie auction results

Robert Edward Auctions sold three PSA 10 Payton rookies in 2022 and 2023, at $63,000, $55,200 and $48,000.

Each row below is one auction result with the auction house and the date it closed.

CardGradePriceSold at
Walter Payton #148 rookie, signedPSA 7 / Auto 10$280,600Heritage Auctions, Mar 2, 2026
Walter Payton #148 rookieSGC 100 (Gold Label Pristine)$228,000Heritage Auctions, Feb 26, 2021
Walter Payton #148 rookiePSA 10$124,230Venue not stated, Mar 8, 2021
Walter Payton #148 rookiePSA 10$98,405.20Venue not stated, Aug 6, 2026
Walter Payton #148, rookiePSA 10$81,000Fanatics Collect, Dec 19, 2025
Walter Payton #148 rookie, signedCGC 8 / Auto 9$73,200Heritage Auctions, Sep 18, 2026
Walter Payton #148, rookiePSA 10$63,000Robert Edward Auctions, Fall 2022
Walter Payton #148, rookiePSA 10$55,200Robert Edward Auctions, Spring 2023
Walter Payton #148, rookiePSA 10$48,000Robert Edward Auctions, Fall 2023

Before you price a 1976 Payton

Gem copies are what bring these prices. Check the grade on the slab first.

Keep a 1976 run in number order with a simple binder layout for sports cards. If a card looks off, read how an error differs from a variation.

BinderMint can show eBay asking prices beside each card you add. Free for your first 99 cards. No credit card needed.

FAQ

What is the highest price for a 1976 Topps Walter Payton rookie?

$280,600 for a signed copy graded PSA 7 / Auto 10, through Heritage Auctions on March 2, 2026.

What did a PSA 10 1976 Topps Walter Payton sell for?

$81,000 with buyer's premium at Fanatics Collect on December 19, 2025.

Has the Payton rookie gone up in value?

In these auction results, yes. A gem copy brought $48,000 at Robert Edward Auctions in Fall 2023, then $81,000 at Fanatics Collect in December 2025.

Last checked 16 November 2026.

Sources

Related