What are the most valuable 1990s football cards?
Short answer: As of November 2026, the top 1990s football sale is the one-of-one 1998 Metal Universe Gem Master #20 Barry Sanders, which sold for $512,400 in PSA 7 (MBA Gold) at the Heritage Auctions Summer Platinum Auction in August 2026. The top Peyton Manning sale is the 1998 SkyBox Metal Universe Gem Masters #189 at $414,800 in PSA 8.5 at Heritage in August 2026.
Six big 1990s football sales
Each row is a single reported sale of one copy in one grade. Manning holds the next three spots, and a Brett Favre rookie insert from 1991 rounds out the decade.
| Card | Grade | Price | Sold at | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1998 Metal Universe Gem Master #20 Barry Sanders 1/1 | PSA 7 (MBA Gold) | $512,400 | Heritage Auctions Summer Platinum Auction | August 2026 |
| 1998 SkyBox Metal Universe Gem Masters #189 Peyton Manning | PSA 8.5 | $414,800 | Heritage Auctions | August 2026 |
| 1998 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket autograph, Peyton Manning | PSA 10 | $207,400 | Heritage Auctions | August 2025 |
| 1998 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket autograph, Peyton Manning | PSA 10 | $176,900 | Reported by Heavy | April 2026 |
| 1991 Wild Card #119 Brett Favre, "1000" stripe | PSA 10 | $18,600 | Fanatics auction | February 8, 2026 |
| 1998 SP Authentic #14 Peyton Manning | PSA 10 | $9,300 | Robert Edward Auctions | January 2023 |
What pushed these cards so high?
Scarcity did most of the work. Sports Collectors Digest describes the Sanders card as a one-of-one. Heavy describes the Gem Masters Manning as the only copy made, and that one card outsold every autographed Manning rookie. The Favre is the "1000" stripe version of his Wild Card rookie.
Most 1990s football cards were printed in large runs, so a base rookie rarely comes near these figures. Inserts, autographs and numbered parallels are where the big money sits. Check whether a card in your box is a stripe or parallel version with our error and variation guide, then file the keepers using a page-by-page filing plan.
Snap the card on any table and BinderMint names it and shows its eBay asking price.
FAQ
Which 1990s football card has the highest sale?
In this list, the one-of-one 1998 Metal Universe Gem Master #20 Barry Sanders at $512,400 in PSA 7 (MBA Gold), Heritage Auctions, August 2026. The top Peyton Manning sale is $414,800 in PSA 8.5, also at Heritage in August 2026.
What did the Manning Contenders autograph sell for?
$207,400 in PSA 10 at Heritage in August 2025, and $176,900 for a PSA 10 in April 2026.
Is the 1991 Wild Card Favre worth anything?
The "1000" stripe version in PSA 10 sold for $18,600 at a Fanatics auction on February 8, 2026. Check the stripe on the front of yours.
Does a 1998 SP Authentic Manning sell high?
A PSA 10 sold for $9,300 at Robert Edward Auctions in January 2023.
Last checked 16 November 2026.
Sources
- Heavy: Peyton Manning rookie card sells for record $414,800
- Sports Illustrated: 1991 Wild Card Brett Favre 1000 Stripe PSA 10 sets new record
- Robert Edward Auctions: 1998 SP Authentic #14 Peyton Manning PSA 10
- Sports Collectors Digest: Barry Sanders and Peyton Manning cards in the Heritage Summer Platinum Auction