BinderMint

Which Emmitt Smith cards are worth the most?

By Al Davies · Updated

Short answer: As of November 2026, the top Emmitt Smith card sale is a 1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Green #126 numbered 1/15, which sold for $66,000 in PSA 8 at a Fanatics Collect Premier Auction on May 23, 2025. His best known rookie, the 1990 Score Supplemental #101T, sells far lower, at $1,516.80 in PSA 10 at SCP Auctions in October 2021.

Emmitt Smith sales by card

Each row is one auction result for one copy, with the buyer's premium included.

CardGradePriceSold atDate
1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Green #126, numbered 1/15PSA 8$66,000Fanatics Collect (Premier Auction)May 23, 2025
1998 Fleer Brilliants 24 Karat Gold #4TG, numbered to 24PSA 8$15,900Fanatics CollectApr 17, 2026
1998 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems #42, numbered to 50BGS 8.5$13,800Fanatics Collect (Premier Auction)Aug 29, 2025
1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Red #126, numbered to 150BGS 9$12,600Fanatics Collect (Premier Auction)Jun 19, 2026
1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Red #126, numbered to 150PSA 6.5$8,700Fanatics Collect (Premier Auction)May 22, 2026
1990 Score Supplemental #101T rookiePSA 10$1,516.80SCP AuctionsOct 2021
1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Red #126, numbered to 150PSA 8$1,410Fanatics CollectJun 2026
1990 Score Supplemental #101T rookiePSA 10$1,200SCP AuctionsApr 2025

Low print runs beat the rookie

Late 1990s inserts with small print runs, such as the Precious Metal Gems Green numbered 1/15, the Brilliants gold numbered to 24 and the Precious Metal Gems red numbered to 150, sold near or above a gem mint copy of his rookie while graded only PSA 8.

The Score Supplemental rookie in PSA 10 went from $1,516.80 in 2021 to $1,200 in 2025 at the same auction house, so the date of a sale matters as much as the grade.

Keeping Smith cards in order

Match the set name and card number on the back, such as #101T for the Score Supplemental rookie, before you compare a sale. A guide on print errors and variations shows what else can change a card's identity, and a binder layout for sports cards keeps a Cowboys run together.

No binder needed. Snap the card on any table and BinderMint names it and shows its eBay asking price.

FAQ

What is the most valuable Emmitt Smith card?

The highest sale here is the 1997 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Green #126 numbered 1/15, at $66,000 in PSA 8 at a Fanatics Collect Premier Auction on May 23, 2025.

What did a PSA 10 Score Supplemental Smith rookie sell for?

$1,516.80 at SCP Auctions in October 2021 and $1,200 at SCP Auctions in April 2025.

Do numbered Smith inserts sell well in mid grades?

A Precious Metal Gems Red numbered to 150 sold for $1,410 in PSA 8 at Fanatics Collect in June 2026.

Last checked 16 November 2026.

Sources

Related