What are BGS subgrades and a Black Label?
Short answer: BGS subgrades are four separate scores for centering, corners, edges and surface, and a Black Label is a BGS card that earns a perfect 10 on all four.
What are the four BGS subgrades?
Beckett scores each card on centering, corners, edges and surface. Each score runs from 1 to 10 in half-point steps.
The slab label prints all four numbers next to the overall grade. You can see where a card lost points, not just the final number.
What does a BGS Black Label mean?
A Black Label is a BGS 10 with a 10 in every subgrade. The label has a black background instead of the usual colors.
Black Labels are very rare. Grading guides put them at under 1 percent of BGS submissions. Compare how many copies reached each grade with the PSA population report guide.
How is a BGS 10 different from a Black Label?
Both are called a 10, but the subgrades differ. A Black Label needs four perfect 10 scores. A card with a lower subgrade can still reach a 10 overall, and it gets the standard Pristine label.
Check the label before you pay a Black Label price. The overall number alone does not tell you which one you have.
Why do collectors compare BGS 9.5 to PSA 10?
A BGS 9.5 is the usual top-grade counterpart to a PSA 10 in market talk. The extra detail in subgrades is one reason some buyers prefer BGS. Prices still depend on recent sales for the exact card.
The guide on PSA vs BGS vs SGC compares the three companies side by side.
How do you use subgrades before you submit?
Centering is the one subgrade you can check at home. Follow the steps in the centering guide before you spend money on grading.
Then read raw versus graded cards to decide if grading pays off. When the card comes back, scan it into BinderMint so it sits with the rest of your collection.
To plan a submission, see what Beckett charges by tier.
FAQ
What is a BGS Black Label?
A BGS 10 card with a perfect 10 in centering, corners, edges and surface.
Is a BGS Pristine 10 the same as a Black Label?
No. Both are 10 overall. Only the Black Label has four 10 subgrades.
Do BGS subgrades use half points?
Yes. Each subgrade runs from 1 to 10 in half-point steps.
How rare is a Black Label?
Very rare. Grading guides put it at under 1 percent of BGS submissions.
Last checked 28 October 2026.
Sources
- Collector's Guide: Grading with Beckett, Rare Candy
- Grading Guide BGS, Pregrade Cards
- Beckett Card Grading (BGS) guide, CardGrade